9 Viable Ways to Have a Trial Separation in the Same House

Listen to this article

Research suggests that a trial separation provides couples with the opportunity to take time apart, giving them space to work on their relationship without each other’s immediate influence.

But can this be true when the separation happens while living together?

Couples who attempt a trial separation within the same house may, in fact, have better communication outcomes than those who live apart. This happens because the approach allows couples to work on their relationship without the upheaval of moving out, providing a unique space to evaluate.

Imagine this: You and your partner are at a crossroads, unsure if separation is the answer, but the thought of living apart feels too final. 

Instead, you decide to give each other space while staying under the same roof, handling a trial separation in the same house. It’s a situation that’s both challenging and hopeful—a chance to reflect on your relationship without making any drastic moves.

In this guide, we’ll walk you through nine practical and actionable ways on how to do a trial separation in the same house. These tips are designed to help you create boundaries, communicate effectively, and truly understand what you both need moving forward.

How is trial separation different from in-house separation?

When it comes to giving your relationship a break, you might consider either a trial separation or an in-house separation. But what’s the difference?

Trial separation is where one or both partners physically move out of the shared home to live separately for a period. The idea is to give each person space to reflect on the relationship without the daily influence of the other.

In-house separation involves both partners staying in the same home but living as separately as possible. Think of it as setting boundaries within your shared space, giving each other room to breathe while still under the same roof.

If you’re wondering how to have a trial separation in the same house, the in-house method can be a viable first step before deciding on a full trial separation.

Here’s a quick look at how these two approaches compare:

Does in-house separation work?

In-house separation can feel like walking a tightrope—it requires balance, communication, and a clear understanding of boundaries. 

For some couples, it can be a lifeline, offering the space needed to reevaluate the relationship without the upheaval of moving out. But for others, it can be a recipe for confusion and further conflict..

Situations where it can work

• If both partners agree on the rules and respect each other’s space, a trial separation in the same house can create the distance needed to reflect on the relationship without the finality of a physical separation.
• When moving out isn’t financially feasible, living separately within the same house can provide a practical solution while still allowing for some emotional distance.
• For couples with children, staying under the same roof can minimize disruption to the kids’ lives while the parents work through their issues.

Situations where it cannot work:

• If the relationship is marked by frequent arguments or unresolved issues, staying in the same house can exacerbate tensions, making the situation worse rather than better.
• Without clear boundaries, in-house separation can lead to blurred lines, confusion, and mixed signals, preventing either partner from gaining the clarity needed.
• If one or both partners rely heavily on each other for emotional support, remaining in close proximity can hinder the purpose of the separation, which is to gain perspective and independence.

Self-answering deciding factors

Why do couples undergo trial separation in the same house?

Deciding to separate is never easy, and sometimes moving out just isn’t an option. That’s where a trial separation while living in the same house comes into play. 

It’s a unique approach that lets couples explore their relationship dynamics without making any drastic changes. But why do couples choose this path? Here are five reasons:

1. Financial constraints make moving out difficult

Let’s face it—living separately can be expensive. Renting a new place, paying for utilities, and managing two households can quickly add up. 

For couples who are already feeling the financial strain, a trial separation when living in the same house offers a more affordable way to create space without the burden of extra costs.

2. Minimizing disruption for children

When kids are involved, keeping their lives as stable as possible is often a top priority. Parents may choose to stay under the same roof to maintain a sense of normalcy for their children. 

A trial separation while living in the same house allows parents to navigate their relationship issues while still being present for their kids’ daily routines.

3. Creating space without finality

Sometimes, couples aren’t ready to make a final decision about their relationship. A trial separation when living in the same house gives them the chance to step back and reassess without the permanence of moving out. 

It’s a way to hit pause, reflect, and see if some distance can help resolve issues.

4. Testing the waters before making big decisions

For couples who are unsure whether separation or divorce is the right move, staying in the same house provides a low-risk way to test the waters. 

It allows them to experience the dynamics of living separately while still being close enough to communicate and reconsider their options before making any major changes.

5. Maintaining access to shared resources

Whether it’s shared responsibilities, like caring for pets, or simply the convenience of living in the same home, couples might opt for in-house separation to maintain access to these shared resources. 

This setup allows them to continue fulfilling their daily obligations while giving each other the emotional space needed to figure things out.

How to have a trial separation in the same house: 9 practical ways

Taking a step back from your relationship doesn’t always mean moving out. A trial separation in the same house offers a unique opportunity to evaluate your relationship while maintaining the comforts of home. 

But how do you make it work without stepping on each other’s toes? Here are five practical ways to navigate this delicate situation.

1. Establish separate living spaces within the home

To make an in-house separation work, it’s crucial to carve out distinct areas where each person can retreat. This could mean one partner takes the bedroom while the other moves to a spare room or even the living room. The key is to create a sense of independence within shared walls.

Example: If you’re taking the bedroom, set up a cozy space in the living room for your partner with their own TV and work area, ensuring each person has privacy.

2. Set clear boundaries around interactions

Without clear boundaries, it’s easy to slip back into old habits. Decide on specific times and places where interactions will be limited. This helps both partners to focus on themselves and gives the separation a sense of structure.

Example: Agree to avoid kitchen conversations during meal prep and instead, use scheduled check-ins for any discussions, keeping day-to-day interactions minimal.

Learn more about setting boundaries during the separation period with this insightful video:

3. Maintain separate routines to foster independence

Having your own routine is vital during a trial separation. This includes different meal times, separate social activities, and even different sleep schedules. The goal is to live as independently as possible while sharing the same space.

Example: If you usually have breakfast together, consider eating at different times or even in different rooms to establish a sense of independence.

4. Communicate openly about expectations and goals

Clear communication is key to ensuring the separation serves its purpose. Both partners should discuss what they hope to achieve and set realistic expectations. Regular check-ins can help track progress and adjust boundaries as needed.

Example: Schedule a weekly meeting to discuss how the separation is going, focusing on what’s working and what needs to be adjusted to meet both partners’ goals.

5. Create a plan for handling shared responsibilities

Shared responsibilities, like paying bills, cooking, or caring for pets, can become tricky during a trial separation. Develop a plan that divides these tasks fairly while respecting the separation.

Example: If you both used to cook dinner together, alternate nights or prepare meals separately to maintain distance while still managing daily responsibilities.

6. Limit social media interactions to avoid confusion

During a trial separation, it’s important to avoid mixed signals, especially on social media. Limiting or even pausing social media interactions can prevent misunderstandings and help maintain the boundaries you’ve set within the home.

Example: If you usually comment on each other’s posts, agree to refrain from doing so during the separation to avoid any confusion or mixed messages.

7. Set financial boundaries and manage expenses separately

Money matters can complicate a trial separation if not handled carefully. Establish clear financial boundaries, such as managing personal expenses separately, while still contributing fairly to shared household costs.

Example: If you share a bank account, consider setting up separate accounts for personal spending while maintaining the joint account for bills and household expenses.

8. Create an exit strategy for when emotions run high

Living together during a trial separation can lead to unexpected emotional flare-ups. Having a plan in place for when things get tense can help both partners cool down without escalating the situation.

Example: If a conversation gets heated, agree that one of you will leave the house for a short walk or visit a friend to give each other space to calm down.

9. Respect each other’s privacy and personal time

Even though you’re sharing the same space, respecting each other’s privacy is crucial. Give each other the freedom to pursue personal interests, hobbies, or even new social activities without interference or judgment.

Example: If your partner decides to take up a new hobby or spend time with friends, allow them that space without questioning or intruding, just as you would expect in return.

A path to clarity and growth

Taking the step towards an in-house separation isn’t just about creating distance—it’s about finding clarity in the comfort of familiar surroundings. It’s a journey that requires patience, respect, and a willingness to explore your relationship from a new perspective. 

Know that the goal isn’t just to figure out whether to stay together or part ways, but to truly understand each other and yourselves. This experience can be a catalyst for growth, offering both partners the chance to reflect, heal, and potentially rebuild a stronger connection. 

So, as you move forward, embrace the process, stay open to what you discover, and trust that whatever the outcome, you’re making strides towards a more authentic and fulfilling life.