How to Choose Between Two Guys: 20 Tips to Make a Decision

So, you are trying to settle down and looking for a partner who will cherish you with his love. But there is a twist. You have two men vying for your attention.

You like both of them. They are successful and give you attention, which often causes many dilemmas in your mind. You have spent sleepless nights thinking how to choose between two guys for marriage!

But, unfortunately, you still haven’t found the right direction on how to choose between two guys who have feelings for you. It is not a crime to have feelings for more than one person simultaneously. But you have to beat the stress and choose one of the two.

No, nobody is going to blame or judge you. Instead, here you will find some exciting solutions for how to choose a boyfriend between two guys or a marriage partner. So, read on to know more!

Is it possible to be in love with two different guys simultaneously?

You are confused and find ways to choose between two guys. On top of that, you are hurt and conflicted as you have feelings for two guys simultaneously. It may seem unethical to you. But yes, it can happen.

Sometimes, women can fall in love with two guys at the same time. This is called polyamory, or simultaneously having romantic feelings for two different persons.

Psychologists say having a romantic interest in two different people simultaneously is normal. As a woman, you have certain criteria in your subconscious mind about your partner’s personality traits. In some cases, you may encounter two men who all sport your desired qualities. So, it is possible.

Humans have been monogamous by their own choice for a long time. The idea of living and spending life with a particular person is so common that you may think it is impossible to be in love with two people.

However, polyamory is often stressful, and research says that women who have such feelings might think more about how to choose between two guys and become stressed and depressed.

Whatever the case, it is not a sin or an uncanny thing. It is purely psychological, and you may need to think better about choosing between two guys to get over the dilemma.

What are the key factors when choosing between two great potential partners?

Choosing is never easy when we have two excellent options. However, when it comes to choosing a partner, things can become more complicated. When choosing between two potential partners, there are several key factors to consider. 

First of all, compatibility plays a crucial role between partners. Evaluate how well your values, goals, and interests align with each partner. Also, look for someone who can effectively and openly communicate and work with you to establish a healthy and supportive relationship. 

Besides that, consider each partnership’s trust, respect, and mutual understanding level. Finally, assess the level of emotional and physical attraction you feel towards each partner.

How vital are shared interests in deciding between two amazing guys?

When we have something in common, it’s easy to form bonds. Shared interests can play a significant role in deciding between two amazing partners. Having common activities or hobbies can provide a foundation for bonding and creating mutual experiences. 

Shared interests can facilitate communication and connection, providing a common ground to build upon. Engaging in joint activities and conversations related to shared interests can enhance the depth of the relationship. 

Moreover, having common interests can contribute to compatibility and understanding between partners. However, it is essential to note that shared interests should not be the sole determining factor in choosing a partner, as compatibility on other levels is also crucial.

How to choose between two guys: 20 tips to help you decide

You are in a moral dilemma because you can’t choose between two lovers. You are happy being in a relationship with two guys. But, on the flip side, you know that you have to settle down with one of them.

On top of that, you do not want to cause heartbreak for any of these two men. But you know that you have to make a tough choice.

Because you are struggling inside, you want to make peace with yourself by finding the best possible answer against how to choose between two guys who are friends. Well, the journey is indeed tricky. So, here are some tips on how to choose between two guys:

1. Try to find out more about their personalities

Even if you like these two men, they differ from the core. The best method to choose between two guys is to find as many details as possible about their personalities.

Try to find out about their hobbies, family members, relationships with their families, personal preferences, food habits, vacation habits, etc. You will find that there is someone more suitable for your ideals. Go for that man only.

2. Check out how you spend time with each of them

Are you still confused about how to pick between two guys you love? So, try this method of dating two guys! Check out how their behavior changes when you spend a long time together.

Which of them makes you happier and safer? Who brings out the best in you? You will indeed find your answer.

3. Check out the negative qualities of each man

Unsure about how to choose between two guys at this moment? Look out for their negative qualities. If you want to spend your life with someone, you must know their negative traits.

Who makes fun of you often in the wrong way? Are there any anger issues? Which seems more self-centered and loves to get the opposite sex’s attention? Find answers to the above questions; you will understand whom you must choose!

4. Ask what they want from their life (and you)

You are looking for your life partner. Hence, you need to check if the man you choose has the right plans. Hence, when confused between two guys, ask them about their plans.

You will slowly realize that there is someone whose plans do not match your ideologies. He may not be the right one for you!

5. Never decide based on physical appearance

Want the best advice on choosing between two people? Never choose according to their appearance. And on top of that, do not compare their physical appearances to find the best one.

Physical appearance can only cause a need for money. But, with the right person, you will always feel a deep mental and physical connection. On top of that, a man’s personality makes him attractive! Choose wisely, girls!

6. Check out how each of them feels about you

When choosing between two men, try to consider their feelings once. They will not be the same even if they have romantic feelings for you.

Hence, try to find out what they feel about you and how they want to plan their future with you. You will get your answer!

7. Is there any moral clash?

There is another solution on how to decide between two guys. That is to compare the moral ideologies of the two guys. Check out if you are clashing with these guys on moral issues. 

One of them might share similar ideologies with you, while the other may have conflicting ideas. It is better to choose who shares the same beliefs as you! After all, it is a matter of your life!

8. Who is more interested in settling down?

So, you are confused about the two guys equally smitten by you. But, in the end, you have to choose only one person. So, how to choose between two men you love?  

Well, by checking out their eagerness to settle down. Ask them about their plans to settle down with you.

While men may have feelings for you, some are more serious than others. Ideally, you should choose a man eager to settle down with you and maintain that stand.

If a guy is keen to settle down with you, he will start planning about the future and may even set some long-term family goals. Ask and check out how they have planned their life with you.

So, it is better to go with the guy who plans to marry within a few years!

9. Who is there to cheer you at your lowest point?

Relationships are not about love and sweet moments. It is also about supporting each other and helping each other find an anchor in the difficult times of your life.

Check out who is there to cheer you up after you are upset. The man who comforts you during your lowest times is the ideal partner. After all, you will need a shoulder to cry on when sad.

On top of that, check out who helps you when stressed due to personal and professional issues. You will indeed find out. This method of choosing between two guys you love never fails!

10. Who is more family-oriented?

So, you are confused about how to know which guy to choose. Have you tried to find who is more family-oriented?

A guy who loves his family will always be a great man to start your own family. Check out who talks more about his family in your presence. See who out of these two guys asks for your help to choose gifts for their parents or siblings.

A real family-oriented guy will also invite you to meet with his family once in a while! Understand that this man is undoubtedly husband material!

11. Which of them is friendlier with children?

Wondering, “Which guy should I choose?” Then follow this tip. Check out which of these guys are friendlier with children. A guy who understands children better and is comfortable while caring for them will be a more responsible father figure.

Check out which of these guys love their nephews or niece or spend time with children regularly. Also, ask them how they feel while being asked to care for children! It will help you to decide better!

12. Who has the qualities of a real man?

You need an honest and dependable man who will always be there with you through thick and thin. So, why not apply this principle to how to choose between two guys?

Who among these is respectful toward everyone, even strangers? Who always talks politely and does not make a scene, even when angry? Who opens their hand to help people in need? Who is there to offer helping hands to the neighborhood during any issues?

Seek the answers and then decide.

13. Who is trying harder to impress you?

Are you torn between two guys? Then, check out the efforts of each of them. Even if they both have romantic feelings, they will have different approaches to impress you.

Instead of thinking, “I like two guys, what should I do?” let their actions speak. One of them will try harder to impress you. You will find him doing everything possible to make you fall for him. Choose that one!

14. What about their past?

No, judging a person by their past is not a good habit. But, this is a matter of relationships. So, make this an exception.

Modern research tells us that people have the same pattern in their relationships. Hence, ask these men about their past relationship histories and thoughts about their past flings. Having decent knowledge about their past may help you choose the right person to some extent!

15. Who has a more positive outlook on life?

Life is about hurdles and challenges. But having a positive outlook can help you sail through even the most turbulent storm.

It would help to have someone who offers you a positive mindset and is always eager to find the silver lining in difficult situations. Find the man who gives you confidence and support to carry on, even during the most challenging phases, with positivity

16. Imagine life with each of them

Still confused about how to choose between two guys you love? Then why not get into some imaginary situations?

Try to imagine your life with each of them. Which one looks comfortable and closer to a good and uneventful life? If you find it easier to imagine a promising future with one of them, go for that man!

17. Who accepts you as you are?

While dating a man and, most importantly, finding your partner, you need to check out their mentality about you. A good man who truly loves you will never try to change you. He will accept you as you are and accept your flaws as a part of you.

So, check out who always tries to change your personality and dressing sense to his liking. A little suggestion is all right, but telling you always to change something is not a good sign either.

18. Ask your friends or family members

Some people may say you should not discuss such matters with your friends. But it is good to talk about life issues once in a while. So, if you have issues deciding between two guys, you can get help.

Ask your close friends or family members. Talk in detail with them about each man’s qualities and negative traits. They may provide you with some solutions. But please remember always to take their advice with a pinch of salt!

19. Ask yourself

Never refuse your gut feeling while choosing between two guys! Probably, your mind and heart know the answer already. You have to believe in your gut instinct once in a while. 

If your gut feeling tells you something is wrong among one of these men, believe in it. Your intuition never goes wrong!

Watch Stephanie Labossiere, a relationship expert, as he guides you through what questions to ask a man before getting married in this video:

20. Consult a therapist

If you have not found any sustainable answer to choosing between two guys you love, it is time to get professional help. It is not unnatural to seek a therapist when you are confused and stressed over relationship issues.

A therapist can help you navigate between the issues and may even help you decide on the most dependable guy among these two men you are involved with!

How can I be sure I chose the right guy?

Well, there is nothing like this. You have made the conscious decision to choose between two guys you love. So, it is time to concentrate on your choice. Yes, with time, people can change.

But, have faith in your decision and love. As you move forward with him, you will find new ways to mend gaps and bridges together. So, be sure of your decision and jump in the wagon!

FAQs

When choosing between two guys you love, it’s natural to have doubts. In this section, we have answered some commonly asked questions regarding choosing a partner. 

• How do I know if I’m ready to make a decision?

Decision-making comes with a sense of readiness when you have gathered sufficient information, weighed the pros and cons, and assessed its potential impact. Trust your instincts and listen to your intuition. If you feel confident and have considered the relevant factors, you are ready to decide between two guys.

• What if I’m still undecided after trying all the tips?

If you have explored various tips and techniques but are still deciding between partners, take a step back. Reflect on why you may be struggling to make a choice. 

Consider seeking advice from trusted individuals or professionals offering a fresh perspective. Sometimes, giving yourself more time and space can lead to clarity and a better understanding of what you truly want.

• How do I deal with the guilt of hurting someone’s feelings?

Dealing with the guilt of hurting someone’s feelings can be challenging. Remember that you are responsible for your happiness and well-being. Acknowledge your emotions, be compassionate, and understand that you can’t please everyone. Communicate your intentions respectfully and honestly, and offer support if possible.

• What if I end up regretting my decision?

Regret is a common fear associated with decision-making. While it’s natural to feel regret when you choose one partner out of two people you love, try not to dwell on it. Instead, view it as an opportunity for growth and learning. 

Recognize that you made the best decision when deciding between the partners. Reflect on the lessons learned and apply them to future decision-making processes, allowing yourself to progress and grow.

• How can I move on if I choose the wrong guy?

If you find yourself in a situation where you realize you chose the wrong partner, it’s crucial to prioritize your well-being. Reflect on why the relationship didn’t work out and what you have learned from it. 

Give yourself time to heal and focus on self-care. Surround yourself with a support system, engage in activities you enjoy, and keep an open mind for new opportunities.

Wrapping up

It is not abnormal to have romantic feelings for two guys at once. But, it would help if you found the answers to “How do I choose between two guys?” to get over all the complications. Take your time and think properly to make the decision.

It may be a lengthy and conflicting procedure. But, you will find the right person after a long thinking procedure. After choosing, stick to your decision and be prepared to be the other person in your life.

It is better to have a stable relationship than two conflicted ones! Hence, take your time and take a step toward your dream guy!

Continue exploring this topic

Talk to our Marriage.com AI Relationship Coach

Chat with me, ask questions and get help

Start Chatting

Marriage.com AI: Your Relationship Guide

Talk through what's on your mind.

Automated

Hi, I'm your relationship guide. What's on your mind?

YOU COULD START WITH

How can I choose between two guys?

What are some tips to decide between two men?

AI guidance only - not therapy. In crisis? Call a helpline or Find a Therapist

Terms

Sylvia Smith Author

Sylvia Smith loves to share insights on how couples can revitalize their love lives in and out of the bedroom. As a writer at Marriage.com, she is a big believer in living consciously and encourages couples to adopt this principle... Read more in their lives too. Sylvia believes that every couple can transform their relationship into a happier, healthier one by taking purposeful and wholehearted action. Read less

Marriage.com Assessment

What Help Does Your Relationship Need Most Right Now Quiz

Reviewed byJennifer Schulz, LCSW

Backed by relationship science and evidence-based psychology, this assessment helps identify the area of your relationship that deserves the most attention right now, whether things feel strong or slightly off. Research shows that even healthy relat...

Questions: 20 | Last updated: Jan 23, 2026

Sample Question

When you and your partner talk about something important…

We listen with care — even hard talks feel safe and productive

We try to talk, but lately emotional closeness feels harder to reach

I want to be open, but part of me still guards my heart

Our discussions sometimes spiral or end unresolved

It’s hard to feel close because our physical intimacy hasn’t felt strong lately

We often see things differently about goals or priorities

Take the Quiz Now