16 Things to Do When He Chooses Someone Else Over You

One of the worst relationship issues that can happen to you is when he chooses someone else over you. This situation can leave you devastated and confused. You might ask yourself, “Why did he choose her over me?” or “Why does he love her and not me?”

These questions can sometimes overwhelm and frustrate you because many scenarios will keep playing in your mind. You might even blame yourself, but no one is at fault. Life is far more complicated than that. It’s normal to ask questions like the above when he chooses someone else over you.

After all, you were building a life together and thought you would end up together. However, things do not always go according to plan for many reasons. The best thing to do is to move on, even though it’s hard.

Many have asked, “What makes a man choose another woman over you?” Why would any man decide to leave a seemingly beautiful woman for another? Keep reading to find out.

What makes a man choose another woman over you?

When someone leaves you for someone else, you need to understand that you might not be at fault. You must know this because the first thing some women do is to wallow in self-blame. There are many reasons attached when he leaves you for someone else.

First, love is irrational – you can love another person without any tangible reason. People, including you, have no control over who they choose to love. 

That makes you start comparing yourself with the other girl or asking, “Why did he choose her over me?” or “Why does he love her and not me?”

What you should not do is self-blame. Thinking about the other girl or wishing you had some of her bodily features or lifestyle will only affect your self-esteem. Understand that it is not your fault when he chooses someone else over you.

The following reasons could be at play when someone leaves you for someone else:

1. Sexual compatibility

Sexual compatibility is one of the top reasons a man chooses a woman over another. Many men prefer a woman that matches their sexual styles. These styles may include her moves, how she kisses, how she dresses, and so on.

Understand that she might not even be as beautiful as you are. As long as her sexual appeal attracts the man, he will choose her.

2. Goals

Men are naturally attracted to women whose life goals align with theirs. After satisfactory sexual activities, many men like to know if they can move beyond the present level.

If you have nothing in common, there is a high chance that you will keep falling apart. If you plan to move out of your country, but the man wants to stay, he may go for another woman.

According to Grady Shumway, LCSW, “Shared life goals are one of the strongest foundations for long-term compatibility, and having honest conversations about the future early in a relationship can save both partners significant emotional pain down the road.”

3. Social lifestyle

One of the things men focus on is social compatibility with their love interest. When he leaves you for someone else, the reason could be that you do not fit into his social circle. It hurts, but that’s the way it is. 

A man who attends business meetings, business parties, official gatherings, and business-related dinners would want to bring his partner along. If you detest parties or going out, he would choose another who does.

4. Behavior

Behavior compatibility could be the culprit when someone leaves you for someone else. If your man likes to have time alone with you, but your girls’ time is more important, he will choose another woman.

5. Values and beliefs

When he chooses someone else over you, your different religions could be the impediment. Religion is one reason many people would not say openly because they might appear discriminatory or biased. However, people do leave their love interests because of religious incompatibility.

What do you do when a guy chooses someone else over you?

When someone chooses someone else over you, it can be a painful experience. It’s essential to allow yourself to feel the emotions that come up and focus on self-care while you heal.

If a guy leaves you for another woman, you mustn’t brood over it long. It is normal to cry and get sad since you thought he was the right person. However, it would help if you allowed yourself to move on as quickly as possible.

16 things you should do when he chooses someone else over you 

Sooner or later, you will hopefully find someone who chooses you over everyone else. You just have to look for the right person.

If you still feel like moving on is a challenging feat for you, check the following things to do when he chooses someone else over you.

1. Accept the situation

No matter how much you ask yourself, “Why did he choose her over me? Or “Why does he love her and not me?” you might never get the answer.

What you need to do is to accept the situation as it is. Remember that it is not your fault or anyone’s fault. Besides, incompatibility has happened to everyone at some point in their lives.

2. Let out your emotions

When someone leaves you for someone else, it can be obvious to be heartbroken. However, you don’t need to pretend like it does not hurt. Cry as much as you want after the breakup.

Accepting and addressing your emotions can calm you down and help you adjust to your everyday life. Understand that you have no control over what makes a man choose a woman over another, but you have power over your emotions.

3. Give yourself time

When your man chooses someone else over you, it is best not to rush back into another relationship. That can be detrimental and can affect your new relationship. Instead, take time to heal, eat healthy, and engage in things that help you regain your confidence.

4. Talk to friends and family members

When he chooses someone else over you, one of the things you can do is talk to people around you. That does not mean anybody, but mostly family and friends you trust and can help you improve. Keeping all the negative emotions to yourself only bottles them for later distress.

5. Don’t compare yourself with the other woman

A mistake you should avoid when he leaves you for someone else is to compare yourself with the other lady. Do not look for imperfections in your body. You are perfect the way you are; he just can’t see it. Besides, people are different and created uniquely.

6. Don’t stalk the other woman

It’s human nature to think another person is better than you when he chooses someone else over you. You shouldn’t stalk the other woman in an attempt to know what she does or how she does things. That is a sign of insecurity, and it might mess up your self-esteem.

7. Don’t think about her

You may never know what makes a man choose a woman over another, even if you get inside his head. As stated earlier, love can sometimes be irrational; however, thinking about the other woman will affect your mood. You are different individuals, and no one is better than the other.

8. Remind yourself that you are enough

Asking questions such as “Why did he choose her over me?” “Why does he love her and not me?” are quick ways to unhappiness. Instead, reassure yourself that you are worthy of being loved and adored.

Repeat the statement, “I am worthy and more than enough!” as often as possible. That will help elevate your mood.

9. Enjoy the time you have

A certain freedom comes when someone leaves you for someone else. You have enough time to heal, play around, meet new friends, and possibly love interests. Try to enjoy and make the best of this moment. Remember, life goes on no matter what happens.

10. Stay far away

When a person chooses someone else over you, it is evident that he does not want you in his life. So, why stay around?

It is best to cut him off from your life, especially when you are still healing. Please remove anything that reminds you of him, including his number, social media pages, etc.

11. Don’t take the blame

When he chooses someone else over you, try not to blame yourself. Breakups happen for different reasons, but it does not mean you caused it. Even if you outrightly caused it, blaming yourself will only do more damage to your personality.

Grady Shumway highlights, “Self-reflection after a painful experience is most productive when approached with curiosity and compassion rather than self-criticism, as the goal is growth and understanding rather than assigning fault. If the pattern of relationships you find yourself in feels confusing or repetitive, exploring those dynamics with a therapist can offer valuable insight and help you move forward with greater clarity and self-awareness.”

You parted because you are different humans with different needs. Instead, use the time to self-reflect on the dynamic you bring to relationships. What type of people do you tend to attract to yourself? 

12. Don’t blame the girl

You should not blame the other woman when he chooses someone else over you. She is another person who might not even know you are in the picture. Resenting the other woman will only increase your anger. 

13. Forgive him

What makes a man choose a woman over another will always be a mystery to many women. As such, you need to let go of your grudges against him.

Understandably, you will feel like paying him back, but you must forgive him for your peace. Remember, he has a right to his choices.

Watch Pastor Shawn Johnson as he shares healing steps for handling past hurts that still hurt in this video:

14. Love yourself

When he leaves you for someone else, what you have is YOU, and you have to take care of yourself. Love yourself so much that you have no time to think of him. His choice does not reflect your personality; nobody will love you if you don’t love yourself.

15. Get closure

It is important to get closure if you still have unanswered questions about the relationship that ended. Getting closure will help you move on and avoid resentment towards the situation. 

You can either seek closure from the person who left you or by engaging in self-reflection to find answers to your questions. In getting closure, you’ll free yourself to focus on your future and find happiness in your new path.

16. Move on

Instead of asking, “Why did he choose her over me?” it is best to move on. Ask yourself, “Is this how I want to spend the rest of my life?” You must be the best version of yourself.

Consider immersing yourself in your passions and the things that bring you joy. Allow these interests to envelop you, gradually rekindling your inner happiness and radiance.

And remember, as you embrace your genuine self and continue on this journey, there’s a beautiful possibility that you’ll cross paths with the person you’ve always envisioned as your perfect match, sooner or later.

FAQs

Dealing with unrequited love or being left for someone else can be a challenging and painful experience. It takes time, self-reflection, and patience to heal from such situations. Below, we have answered some commonly asked questions to provide brief insights and advice concerning your queries.

• How long does it take to get over someone who chose someone else?

The time it takes to get over someone who chose someone else varies between individuals. It depends on your emotional connection and how you process the situation. Give yourself space and time to heal, focus on self-care, seek support from loved ones, and engage in activities that bring you joy.

• Can a guy love you but be with someone else?

Yes, it is possible for a guy to love you but be with someone else. It can result from various reasons, such as commitment issues, fear of change, or obligations towards the other person. However, it’s essential to prioritize your emotional well-being.

• What are the signs he has someone else?

Signs that he may have someone else include decreased communication, secretive behavior, constant cancelations or rescheduling of plans, lack of emotional intimacy, sudden change in priorities, becoming defensive or evasive when questioned about his whereabouts or relationship status. Trust your instincts and communicate openly with him to gain clarity.

• How do you accept he left you for someone else?

Accepting that he left you for someone else can be a painful process. Allow yourself to grieve and process your emotions. Remind yourself that it is not a reflection of your worth or desirability. 

Focus on self-care, seek support from friends and family, consider therapy or counseling, and work toward rebuilding your self-esteem and finding happiness.

• Can I still be friends with the person who chose someone else?

Being friends with someone who chose someone else can be complicated and emotionally challenging. It depends on your emotional well-being and the ability to genuinely be friends without lingering romantic feelings. If being friends is too difficult, creating space for yourself and prioritizing your emotional well-being might be better.

To sum up

One of the most heart-wrenching incidents is when he chooses someone else over you. You begin to ask, “Why did he choose her over me?” Understand that no matter how much you try to find out, you can’t know what makes a man choose a woman over another.

However, you can manage your reaction to the situation. The best you can do for yourself is to try to minimize the emotional damages done by the heartbreak and slowly move forward.

Continue exploring this topic

Talk to our Marriage.com AI Relationship Coach

Chat with me, ask questions and get help

Start Chatting

Marriage.com AI: Your Relationship Guide

Talk through what's on your mind.

Automated

Hi, I'm your relationship guide. What's on your mind?

YOU COULD START WITH

What to do when he chooses someone else?

How to cope when he loves someone else?

AI guidance only - not therapy. In crisis? Call a helpline or Find a Therapist

Terms

Rachael Pace Author

Rachael Pace is a noted relationship writer associated with Marriage.com. She provides inspiration, support, and empowerment in the form of motivational articles and essays. Rachael enjoys studying the evolution of loving partnerships... Read more and is passionate about writing on them. She believes that everyone should make room for love in their lives and encourages couples to work on overcoming their challenges together. Read less

Marriage.com Assessment

What Help Does Your Relationship Need Most Right Now Quiz

Reviewed byJennifer Schulz, LCSW

Backed by relationship science and evidence-based psychology, this assessment helps identify the area of your relationship that deserves the most attention right now, whether things feel strong or slightly off. Research shows that even healthy relat...

Questions: 20 | Last updated: Jan 23, 2026

Sample Question

When you and your partner talk about something important…

We listen with care — even hard talks feel safe and productive

We try to talk, but lately emotional closeness feels harder to reach

I want to be open, but part of me still guards my heart

Our discussions sometimes spiral or end unresolved

It’s hard to feel close because our physical intimacy hasn’t felt strong lately

We often see things differently about goals or priorities

Take the Quiz Now