15 Undeniable Signs He Is Pretending Not to Like You

Have you ever noticed a guy looking at you a little longer than usual, only to quickly look away when you catch them? Or maybe you see that certain someone around a lot, but they keep their distance. It’s confusing, isn’t it? 

You might start to wonder if it’s all in your head or if there’s something more going on. Well, in current times, figuring out someone’s true feelings can be tricky. Why would someone hide that they like you? 

It could be because they’re scared of being turned down, or maybe they just want to seem cool and unbothered. It’s paramount to pick up on these subtle signs he is pretending not to like you because they often tell us more than what’s obvious.

15 clear signs he is pretending not to like you

Sometimes, it’s not the words that speak the loudest but the actions that whisper the truth. When someone is pretending not to like you, their true feelings can often seep through their carefully constructed facade. 

If you’re sensing mixed signals, you’re not alone. Here are 15 unmistakable signs he is pretending not to like you, each revealing a bit more about his hidden emotions.

1. He’s always in your orbit

One of the undeniable signs he is pretending not to like you is his omnipresence. You might notice that he’s often around you, even if he doesn’t interact much. 

Whether he shows up at events you attend or frequents places you like, his subconscious desire to be near you can overshadow his outward indifference. 

Such a pattern of “accidentally” being in the same place as you is one of the key indicators he conceals attraction, suggesting a hidden affection that he isn’t quite ready to admit.

2. Overly teasing or joking

If he often teases you or makes you the butt of his jokes, it could be more than simple, playful banter. 

While some might interpret this behavior as disinterest or even annoyance, it can also be a mask for affection, especially if the teasing is gentle and he’s attentive to your reaction. 

It is a classic sign he is pretending not to like you, and he uses humor to express his interest safely without fully exposing his true feelings.

3. He remembers the little things

Despite how he acts outwardly if he remembers small details about your life—your favorite coffee, important dates, or even stories you’ve shared—it’s a significant sign. This level of attentiveness shows he cares enough to listen and retain this information. 

It’s one of the subtle signs he feigns disinterest while actually paying close attention to what matters to you, indicating a deeper level of interest than he’s willing to show openly.

4. His body language gives him away

Body language often tells a different story than words. Signs he is pretending not to like you can include his body pointing toward you when he’s nearby, a lot of eye contact, or mirroring your actions and gestures.

These are involuntary reactions that are hard to control, even if he’s trying to maintain a cool demeanor. If his body language seems to contradict his spoken words, it’s likely that signs he is hiding feelings are literally facing right toward you.

5. He gets jealous or protective

Notice how he reacts when other guys are around you. Does he suddenly seem more attentive or even slightly possessive? Maybe he offers to walk you home or looks out for you in subtle ways. Jealousy and protectiveness are powerful indicators that he cares more than he’s letting on. 

Despite his efforts to appear uninterested, these reactions are signs he is pretending not to like you, revealing that beneath his calm exterior lies a concern and attraction he hasn’t yet voiced.

6. He’s quick to offer help

When a guy goes out of his way to help you, even with trivial things, it’s not just friendly behavior. This proactive approach to be useful in your life can be one of the clues he is masking his love. 

Whether it’s fixing something broken or offering assistance with your work, his readiness to be at your service suggests that he values your well-being and satisfaction, a sign of deeper feelings he might not openly admit.

7. He’s interested in your dating life

If he seems unusually interested in your dating life, asking about your relationship status or reactions to other potential partners, it’s telling. This curiosity often stems from wanting to know his standing in your life and if there’s a chance for him. 

A guy pretending not to care might frame these inquiries as casual or joking, but they can actually be signs he pretends to dislike when, in reality, he’s seeking to gauge if there’s emotional space for him.

8. He avoids deep conversations about his feelings

Another sign is if he consistently shies away from discussing his feelings or deflects deep emotional topics, especially regarding attraction or relationships. This avoidance can be a protective measure to keep his real feelings hidden. 

By keeping conversations light and surface-level, he prevents himself from revealing too much, maintaining a façade of detachment that contradicts the connection you might feel between you.

9. He acts differently when you’re alone together

Pay attention to how his demeanor changes when you’re alone together versus in a group. If he’s more relaxed, engaging, or attentive when no one else is around, it indicates that his public persona of indifference is just an act. 

Such a shift can be one of the subtle signs he is pretending not to like you, as he feels safer showing his true self without the eyes of others judging his actions.

10. Sudden changes in his behavior

Notice any sudden shifts in how he behaves. If he fluctuates between being warm and cold, or if he pulls away after a moment where he seemed particularly close or connected, it’s significant. 

These fluctuations often occur because he’s struggling with his feelings and trying to keep them under wraps. This kind of inconsistent behavior can be frustrating, but it’s a clear indication that he’s not entirely indifferent and perhaps unsure how to proceed with his hidden affections.

11. He engages with your social media

One of the modern-day indications he hides his crush on you is how he interacts with your social media. 

If he consistently likes, comments, or shares your posts but plays it cool in person, it suggests he’s keeping an eye on you while maintaining a façade of disinterest. This digital engagement is a safe way for him to stay connected without exposing his true feelings directly.

12. He finds excuses to touch you

Physical contact can reveal a lot about someone’s feelings. If he looks for small excuses to touch your arm, gently brushes against you, or finds reasons to give high fives, it’s a sign that he’s trying to feel closer to you. 

These subtle physical interactions are often more intentional than they seem, suggesting a level of comfort and attraction that he might not verbally acknowledge.

13. He’s curious about your interests

If he takes a genuine interest in your hobbies and preferences, it’s a sign that he values what makes you happy. This could be as simple as asking about the books you’re reading, the music you like, or suggesting movies that you might enjoy. 

His effort to understand and engage with your interests indicates a deeper level of care and attraction that he might not be ready to admit openly.

Watch this video where relationship coach Stephan Labossiere tells you the clues to look for when you think he is the one:

14. He compliments you subtly

Pay attention to the compliments he gives you. If they’re thoughtful and specific, such as praising your sense of humor, your work ethic, or the way you interact with others, it shows he pays attention to who you are, not just what you look like. 

These compliments, especially when delivered in a low-key manner, are signs he acts uninterested but actually holds a significant appreciation and attraction toward you.

15. He is sensitive to your moods

A final subtle sign is his sensitivity to your emotions. If he can tell when you’re feeling down or stressed and responds by trying to make you feel better, it demonstrates a deep level of empathy and connection. 

Signs that he is uninterested might include pretending these gestures are just friendly support, but in reality, they indicate he cares deeply about your well-being and wants to be someone you can rely on.

FAQs

Understanding why someone might mask their feelings or how to address them can help you deal with social interactions. Here are answers to some common questions about this behavior:

• What are typical reasons someone might pretend not to like you?

People often pretend not to like someone to protect themselves from rejection, hide their vulnerability, or because they feel unsure about how their feelings will be received.

• How can you confront someone who you think is pretending not to like you?

Approach the person in a private, comfortable setting and express your observations and feelings calmly. Ask open-ended questions to encourage them to share their feelings honestly.

• Can misunderstandings be mistaken for someone pretending not to like you?

Yes, misunderstandings, such as misinterpreted actions or words, can sometimes be mistaken for disinterest. Clear communication and asking for clarification can help distinguish between actual disinterest and simple misunderstandings.

• How long do people usually continue pretending before showing their true feelings?

The duration varies widely depending on the individual’s emotional comfort and the context of the relationship. Some might take weeks, while others could take months or even longer to reveal their true feelings.

• What should you do if you find out someone is pretending not to like you?

Reflect on what you want from the relationship. If you’re interested in them, too, consider initiating a frank conversation about your mutual feelings. If not, maintain your boundaries and decide how to interact moving forward, focusing on honest communication.

Final thoughts

As you think about the signs he is pretending not to like you, ask yourself how often you’ve seen them in your own experiences. Is there a deeper connection that hasn’t been talked about yet? 

Recognizing these signs can help you see hidden feelings that someone might be too shy to show. Remember, true feelings often show up in quiet actions and small details. 

If you notice a lot of these signs in someone, it could mean they have feelings for you that they haven’t shared. What will you do with this new understanding, and how might it change your relationship with them?